MDCIS - MI WC Appellate Commission-March 2002 Opinions

March 2002 Opinions

Directions on how to download these forms.

Opinion No. Case Caption Date Mailed Docket

57
Manley, Merri v Norcraft Company 03/01/02 Acrobat   010288

58
Grayson, Susan Ann v Automotive Logistics Services 03/05/02 Acrobat   000186

59
Eckelbecker, Bill E. v U. S. Lumber & Fuel Company 03/05/02 Acrobat   010378

60
Larkin, Eugene S. v St. Joseph Mercy Hospital 03/06/02 Acrobat   010256

61
Sheff, Madaline v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated 03/07/02 Acrobat   010221

62
Vanderbunte, James v Pulpwood & Forestry Products, Incorporated 03/07/02 Acrobat   010244

63
Taylor, Marva v Ludington Components/Haworth, Incorporated 03/11/02 Acrobat   010094

64
Duggan, Patricia v Danny's Food, Incorporated 03/11/02 Acrobat   010126

65
Dakroub, Khalil v American Axle & Manufacturing, Incorporated 03/11/02 Acrobat   010165

66
Gilbert, Kevin v Second Injury Fund (Dual Employment Provisions) 03/11/02 Acrobat   950323

67
Beaufore, Timothy v Federal-Mogul Corporation 03/12/02 Acrobat   010357

67
Becker, David v Federal-Mogul Corporation 03/12/02 Acrobat   010358

67
Fabus, John v Federal-Mogul Corporation 03/12/02 Acrobat   010359

67
Marko, William v Federal-Mogul Corporation 03/12/02 Acrobat   010360

68
Walton, Linda v Sparrow Health System 03/14/02 Acrobat   010315

69
Survillion, Latonya v Wackenhut Corporation 03/14/02 Acrobat   010314

70
Milazzo, Cindylou v Frankenmuth Bavarian Inn 03/18/02 Acrobat   010340

71
Veldman, Burt L. v K-Mart Corporation 03/20/02 Acrobat   990041

72
Parkinson, Lawrence v Detroit Newspaper Agency 03/20/02 Acrobat   000237

73
Russell, Bonita v Michigan Bell Telephone Company 03/22/02 Acrobat   010239

74
Nachbar, Anna v Home Depot USA, Incorporated 03/27/02 Acrobat   010284

75
Martin, Carol A. v Aramark Services, Incorporated 03/29/02 Acrobat   010227

76
Owczarski, Wendy v Citizens Bank 03/29/02 Acrobat   010274

77
Pieser, Richard v Sara Lee Corporation 03/29/02 Acrobat   010207

78
Fifo, Manuel Jr. v Cast North America 83 Trucking Limited 03/29/02 Acrobat   010240

79
Valencia, Felipe v Trans Matic Manufacturing Company 03/29/02 Acrobat   010117

80
Ewing, Judith K. v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated 03/29/02 Acrobat   010161

81
Hahn, Robert J. v Wayland Ford, Incorporated 04/01/02 Acrobat   010249

82
Clifford, Angela v Compuware Corporation 04/02/02 Acrobat   010184

83
Sheppard, Ralph v Blue Care Network, Incorporated 04/03/02 Acrobat   010320

84
Shaughnessy, Patrick v Boice Bird & Sons 04/05/02 Acrobat   010441

85
Rozell, Betty v Technical Auto Parts, Incorporated 04/08/02 Acrobat   010333

86
Beeman, John W. v Family Independence Agency 04/15/02 Acrobat   010196

87
Williamson, Raymond v Berrien County Road Commission 04/16/02 Acrobat   010257

88
Crawford, Lionell v Straight Gate Church 04/16/02 Acrobat   010307

89
Armstrong, James v Connecticut General Life Insurance Company 04/17/02 Acrobat   010075

90
Cardwell, Geraldine v Detroit Board of Education 04/17/02 Acrobat   010096

91
Davis, Martha v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated 04/17/02 Acrobat   010202

92
Taylor, Pete v Lear Seating Corporation 04/17/02 Acrobat   010269

93
Hill, Lenore M. v Adler's Food Town, Incorporated 04/17/02 Acrobat   010420

94
VanDuinen, June v Prince Corporation 04/18/02 Acrobat   010209

95
Onyelobi, Ngozika v Detroit Board of Education 04/18/02 Acrobat   010377

96
Tomlin, Reginald v Plat Construction Company 04/19/02 Acrobat   010110

97
Day, Kim v Thompson McCully Company 04/19/02 Acrobat   010168

98
Gee, Waylon v Arthur B. Myr Industries, Incorporated 04/19/02 Acrobat   010297

99
Magusin, Daniel v Ford Motor Company 04/22/02 Acrobat   010098

100
Land, Charles v Chrysler Corporation 04/22/02 Acrobat   000498

101
Barron, Stanley v Dura Corporation 04/22/02 Acrobat   010247

102
Morren, Andrew v Oosterheert Brothers Siding Company, Incorporated 04/22/02 Acrobat   010354

103
Bedtelyon, Sandra v Saginaw School District 04/22/02 Acrobat   010438

104
Welch, Richard v Allied Erecting & Dismantling Company, Incorporated 04/23/02 Acrobat   010214

105
Mills, William v Guardsman's Products, Incorporated 04/23/02 Acrobat   010222

106
Shelton, Dawna v Detroit Board of Education 04/23/02 Acrobat   010230

107
Anderson, Reed v State of MI, Department of Social Services 04/24/02 Acrobat   010119

108
Ruby, Steven D. v Madison Heights Big Boy 04/25/02 Acrobat   010299

109
Santiago, Martha v MacDonald's Industrial Productions, Incorporated 04/25/02 Acrobat   020073

110
Lapland, Velvet v Rennco, Incorporated 04/25/02 Acrobat   010428

111
Deto, Terry J. v State of MI, Department of Corrections 04/26/02 Acrobat   010325

112
Davila, Lino Jr. v Fisher Corporation 04/30/02 Acrobat   010187

113
Roll, Barbara v Quality Care Dialysis Center of St. Clair Shores
Corrected opinion mailed 5/20/02 05/20/02 Acrobat   010211

114
Sortor, Donald v Fluor Corporation 04/30/02 Acrobat   010334

115
Denton, Donald v Wausau Benefits, Incorporated 04/30/02 Acrobat   010459

116
Lomax, Tonya v Delta Tube & Fabricating Corporation 05/02/02 Acrobat   010352

117
Schilakes, Michael v General Motors Corporation 05/08/02 Acrobat   010375

118
Wiley, Anthony v Promet, Incorporated 05/08/02 Acrobat   010423

119
Kinder, Dennis v City of Burton 05/09/02 Acrobat   010346

120
Brown, Labarrian v Baker Concrete Construction, Incorporated 05/13/02 Acrobat   010295

121
Reiniche, Sharon v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated 05/13/02 Acrobat   010364

122
Maygar, Judy v MFD Grand Blanc, General Motors Corporation 05/16/02 Acrobat   010264

123
Carpenter, Frances v General Motors Corporation 05/20/02 Acrobat   010370

124
Green, Monica v Daimlerchrysler Corporation 05/20/02 Acrobat   010363

125
Smith, Janice v Best Plastics, Incorporated 05/21/02 Acrobat   010304

126
Williams, Naomie v Wayne County 05/22/02 Acrobat   000451

127
Hillard, Sheila v NRG Power Operations, Incorporated 05/22/02 Acrobat   010369

128
Hassigan, Donald v Zantop International Airlines 05/22/02 Acrobat   010455

129
Miller, Rebecca v State of MI, Department of Corrections 05/22/02 Acrobat   020068

130
Cain, Scott M. v Waste Management, Incorporated 05/24/02 Acrobat   980390

131
Burk, William M. v D.M. Mitchell Transport Company 05/24/02 Acrobat   010248

132
Pribanic, Katica v Letica Corporation 05/24/02 Acrobat   010313

133
Hamlin, Gregory v General Motors Corporation 05/24/02 Acrobat   010343

134
Alldaffer, Scott v ABC Beverage Management, Incorporated 05/24/02 Acrobat   010408

135
McConnell, Clifford L. v Pepsi Cola Metropolitan Bottling Company 05/24/02 Acrobat   010431

136
Wright, Helen M. v State of Michigan, Family Independence Agency 05/24/02 Acrobat   010448

137
Wille, Jovita C. v Delphi Automotive Systems Corporation 05/24/02 Acrobat   010476

138
Tepper, Kathleen v Riverside Osteopathic Hospital 05/24/02 Acrobat   010374

139
Beemon, Shirley v Delphi Automotive Systems 05/28/02 Acrobat   010301

140
Taylor, Dewey v Crown Vantage, Incorporated 05/28/02 Acrobat   010381

141
Palmer, Paula v Michaels Stores, Incorporated 05/28/02 Acrobat   010395

142
Thompson, Ruby v Parke Davis/Warner Lambert Company 05/29/02 Acrobat   010489

143
Swander, Brenda L. v Family Dollar Stores 05/29/02 Acrobat   010323

144
Spiteri, George v Rouge Steel Company 05/30/02 Acrobat   010290

145
Braun, Douglas v Plastomer Corporation 05/30/02 Acrobat   020031

146
Zillifro, Rene K. v J. C. Penney Company, Incorporated 05/31/02 Acrobat   010462

147
Green, Francis v G & R Felpausch Company 06/05/02 Acrobat   010342

148
Shaw, Nichelle v Kelly Services, Incorporated 06/06/02 Acrobat   010265

149
Huggins, Lillie B. v Mai Kai Cleaners, Incorporated 06/13/02 Acrobat   010384

150
Yoakum, William v Ford Motor Company 06/13/02 Acrobat   010451

151
Matthews, Marshall v Great Lakes Castings Corporation 06/17/02 Acrobat   000467

152
Draper, Gary L. v Fapco, Incorporated 06/19/02 Acrobat   010355

153
Berrios, Gilda v Conway Central Express d/b/a CCX 06/19/02 Acrobat   010356

154
Wethy, Patricia v General Motors Corporation 06/19/02 Acrobat   010365

155
Ison, Thomas v Book City, Incorporated 06/19/02 Acrobat   010392

156
Benton, Gisela v Delphi Saginaw Steering Systems 06/19/02 Acrobat   010469

157
Kuecken, Dennis v Vincam Human Resources of MI, Incorporated 06/19/02 Acrobat   010398

158
O'Farrell, Robert J. v Shore Mortgage 06/19/02 Acrobat   020046
Acrobat   020099

159
Petrie, Cynthia v Manpower Temporary Services 06/20/02 Acrobat   010306

160
Denslow, Deborah v Evart Products/Textron, Incorporated 06/20/02 Acrobat   010418

161
Long, Gertystine v State of MI, Department of Corrections 06/21/02 Acrobat   000162

162
Gouine, Christopher v Mercury Metalcraft 06/21/02 Acrobat   010376

163
Toth, Patricia v Auto Alliance International, Incorporated 06/21/02 Acrobat   020006

164
Donoho, Mary Ann v Wal-mart Stores, Incorporated 06/26/02 Acrobat   010260

165
Edwards, David v Peerless Gauge, Incorporated 06/27/02 Acrobat   010282

166
Snell, Arthur v Thyssen Steel Group 06/28/02 Acrobat   000091

167
Jackson, Laura v Affiliated Internists 06/28/02 Acrobat   010185

168
Adams, Patricia v Johnson Technology 06/28/02 Acrobat   010347

169
Dubois, Debra v Darden Restaurants, Incorporated 06/28/02 Acrobat   010439

170
Rupley, Thomas v GMC, Delphi Automotive Systems 06/28/02 Acrobat   010465

171
Barkowski, Jacqueline v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated 06/28/02 Acrobat   010481

172
Schmidt, James v Delphi Automotive Systems Corporation 06/28/02 Acrobat   010494

173
Welch, Diane v Metaldyne, Incorporated 07/01/02 Acrobat   010444

174
Whitten, Debbie M. v Genesis Ventures, Incorporated 07/03/02 Acrobat   010443

175
Eriksen, Jimmie v Cotton Regional Correctional Facility 07/08/02 Acrobat   010348

176
Golden, Joan v Detroit Board of Education 07/09/02 Acrobat   010317

177
Rodriguez, Elena v Alterra Healthcare Corporation 07/09/02 Acrobat   020054

178
Adams, Roger Jr. v Griffin Beverage Company 07/09/02 Acrobat   020088

179
Novak, Marcia v Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company 07/09/02 Acrobat   010464

180
Speet, Michael v Barry Haveman 07/11/02 Acrobat   010422

181
Mladin, Gheorghe v C. Firman & Son Construction 07/11/02 Acrobat   020081

182
Clark, Eryne W. Jr. v Supreme Machined Products, Incorporated 07/12/02 Acrobat   010458

183
Morgan, Amy M. v Johnson Controls, Incorporated 07/15/02 Acrobat   010493

Michigan State Government
Department of Consumer and Industry Services
Workers' Compensation Appellate Commission

This page last updated 07/15/2002

http://www.cis.state.mi.us/wkrcomp/wcac/02_03.htm

Opinion No.	Case Caption	Date Mailed	Docket
57	Manley, Merri v Norcraft Company	03/01/02	010288
58	Grayson, Susan Ann v Automotive Logistics Services	03/05/02	000186
59	Eckelbecker, Bill E. v U. S. Lumber & Fuel Company	03/05/02	010378
60	Larkin, Eugene S. v St. Joseph Mercy Hospital	03/06/02	010256
61	Sheff, Madaline v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated	03/07/02	010221
62	Vanderbunte, James v Pulpwood & Forestry Products, Incorporated	03/07/02	010244
63	Taylor, Marva v Ludington Components/Haworth, Incorporated	03/11/02	010094
64	Duggan, Patricia v Danny's Food, Incorporated	03/11/02	010126
65	Dakroub, Khalil v American Axle & Manufacturing, Incorporated	03/11/02	010165
66	Gilbert, Kevin v Second Injury Fund (Dual Employment Provisions)	03/11/02	950323
67	Beaufore, Timothy v Federal-Mogul Corporation	03/12/02	010357
67	Becker, David v Federal-Mogul Corporation	03/12/02	010358
67	Fabus, John v Federal-Mogul Corporation	03/12/02	010359
67	Marko, William v Federal-Mogul Corporation	03/12/02	010360
68	Walton, Linda v Sparrow Health System	03/14/02	010315
69	Survillion, Latonya v Wackenhut Corporation	03/14/02	010314
70	Milazzo, Cindylou v Frankenmuth Bavarian Inn	03/18/02	010340
71	Veldman, Burt L. v K-Mart Corporation	03/20/02	990041
72	Parkinson, Lawrence v Detroit Newspaper Agency	03/20/02	000237
73	Russell, Bonita v Michigan Bell Telephone Company	03/22/02	010239
74	Nachbar, Anna v Home Depot USA, Incorporated	03/27/02	010284
75	Martin, Carol A. v Aramark Services, Incorporated	03/29/02	010227
76	Owczarski, Wendy v Citizens Bank	03/29/02	010274
77	Pieser, Richard v Sara Lee Corporation	03/29/02	010207
78	Fifo, Manuel Jr. v Cast North America 83 Trucking Limited	03/29/02	010240
79	Valencia, Felipe v Trans Matic Manufacturing Company	03/29/02	010117
80	Ewing, Judith K. v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated	03/29/02	010161
81	Hahn, Robert J. v Wayland Ford, Incorporated	04/01/02	010249
82	Clifford, Angela v Compuware Corporation	04/02/02	010184
83	Sheppard, Ralph v Blue Care Network, Incorporated	04/03/02	010320
84	Shaughnessy, Patrick v Boice Bird & Sons	04/05/02	010441
85	Rozell, Betty v Technical Auto Parts, Incorporated	04/08/02	010333
86	Beeman, John W. v Family Independence Agency	04/15/02	010196
87	Williamson, Raymond v Berrien County Road Commission	04/16/02	010257
88	Crawford, Lionell v Straight Gate Church	04/16/02	010307
89	Armstrong, James v Connecticut General Life Insurance Company	04/17/02	010075
90	Cardwell, Geraldine v Detroit Board of Education	04/17/02	010096
91	Davis, Martha v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated	04/17/02	010202
92	Taylor, Pete v Lear Seating Corporation	04/17/02	010269
93	Hill, Lenore M. v Adler's Food Town, Incorporated	04/17/02	010420
94	VanDuinen, June v Prince Corporation	04/18/02	010209
95	Onyelobi, Ngozika v Detroit Board of Education	04/18/02	010377
96	Tomlin, Reginald v Plat Construction Company	04/19/02	010110
97	Day, Kim v Thompson McCully Company	04/19/02	010168
98	Gee, Waylon v Arthur B. Myr Industries, Incorporated	04/19/02	010297
99	Magusin, Daniel v Ford Motor Company	04/22/02	010098
100	Land, Charles v Chrysler Corporation	04/22/02	000498
101	Barron, Stanley v Dura Corporation	04/22/02	010247
102	Morren, Andrew v Oosterheert Brothers Siding Company, Incorporated	04/22/02	010354
103	Bedtelyon, Sandra v Saginaw School District	04/22/02	010438
104	Welch, Richard v Allied Erecting & Dismantling Company, Incorporated	04/23/02	010214
105	Mills, William v Guardsman's Products, Incorporated	04/23/02	010222
106	Shelton, Dawna v Detroit Board of Education	04/23/02	010230
107	Anderson, Reed v State of MI, Department of Social Services	04/24/02	010119
108	Ruby, Steven D. v Madison Heights Big Boy	04/25/02	010299
109	Santiago, Martha v MacDonald's Industrial Productions, Incorporated	04/25/02	020073
110	Lapland, Velvet v Rennco, Incorporated	04/25/02	010428
111	Deto, Terry J. v State of MI, Department of Corrections	04/26/02	010325
112	Davila, Lino Jr. v Fisher Corporation	04/30/02	010187
113	Roll, Barbara v Quality Care Dialysis Center of St. Clair Shores Corrected opinion mailed 5/20/02	05/20/02	010211
114	Sortor, Donald v Fluor Corporation	04/30/02	010334
115	Denton, Donald v Wausau Benefits, Incorporated	04/30/02	010459
116	Lomax, Tonya v Delta Tube & Fabricating Corporation	05/02/02	010352
117	Schilakes, Michael v General Motors Corporation	05/08/02	010375
118	Wiley, Anthony v Promet, Incorporated	05/08/02	010423
119	Kinder, Dennis v City of Burton	05/09/02	010346
120	Brown, Labarrian v Baker Concrete Construction, Incorporated	05/13/02	010295
121	Reiniche, Sharon v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated	05/13/02	010364
122	Maygar, Judy v MFD Grand Blanc, General Motors Corporation	05/16/02	010264
123	Carpenter, Frances v General Motors Corporation	05/20/02	010370
124	Green, Monica v Daimlerchrysler Corporation	05/20/02	010363
125	Smith, Janice v Best Plastics, Incorporated	05/21/02	010304
126	Williams, Naomie v Wayne County	05/22/02	000451
127	Hillard, Sheila v NRG Power Operations, Incorporated	05/22/02	010369
128	Hassigan, Donald v Zantop International Airlines	05/22/02	010455
129	Miller, Rebecca v State of MI, Department of Corrections	05/22/02	020068
130	Cain, Scott M. v Waste Management, Incorporated	05/24/02	980390
131	Burk, William M. v D.M. Mitchell Transport Company	05/24/02	010248
132	Pribanic, Katica v Letica Corporation	05/24/02	010313
133	Hamlin, Gregory v General Motors Corporation	05/24/02	010343
134	Alldaffer, Scott v ABC Beverage Management, Incorporated	05/24/02	010408
135	McConnell, Clifford L. v Pepsi Cola Metropolitan Bottling Company	05/24/02	010431
136	Wright, Helen M. v State of Michigan, Family Independence Agency	05/24/02	010448
137	Wille, Jovita C. v Delphi Automotive Systems Corporation	05/24/02	010476
138	Tepper, Kathleen v Riverside Osteopathic Hospital	05/24/02	010374
139	Beemon, Shirley v Delphi Automotive Systems	05/28/02	010301
140	Taylor, Dewey v Crown Vantage, Incorporated	05/28/02	010381
141	Palmer, Paula v Michaels Stores, Incorporated	05/28/02	010395
142	Thompson, Ruby v Parke Davis/Warner Lambert Company	05/29/02	010489
143	Swander, Brenda L. v Family Dollar Stores	05/29/02	010323
144	Spiteri, George v Rouge Steel Company	05/30/02	010290
145	Braun, Douglas v Plastomer Corporation	05/30/02	020031
146	Zillifro, Rene K. v J. C. Penney Company, Incorporated	05/31/02	010462
147	Green, Francis v G & R Felpausch Company	06/05/02	010342
148	Shaw, Nichelle v Kelly Services, Incorporated	06/06/02	010265
149	Huggins, Lillie B. v Mai Kai Cleaners, Incorporated	06/13/02	010384
150	Yoakum, William v Ford Motor Company	06/13/02	010451
151	Matthews, Marshall v Great Lakes Castings Corporation	06/17/02	000467
152	Draper, Gary L. v Fapco, Incorporated	06/19/02	010355
153	Berrios, Gilda v Conway Central Express d/b/a CCX	06/19/02	010356
154	Wethy, Patricia v General Motors Corporation	06/19/02	010365
155	Ison, Thomas v Book City, Incorporated	06/19/02	010392
156	Benton, Gisela v Delphi Saginaw Steering Systems	06/19/02	010469
157	Kuecken, Dennis v Vincam Human Resources of MI, Incorporated	06/19/02	010398
158	O'Farrell, Robert J. v Shore Mortgage	06/19/02	020046 020099
159	Petrie, Cynthia v Manpower Temporary Services	06/20/02	010306
160	Denslow, Deborah v Evart Products/Textron, Incorporated	06/20/02	010418
161	Long, Gertystine v State of MI, Department of Corrections	06/21/02	000162
162	Gouine, Christopher v Mercury Metalcraft	06/21/02	010376
163	Toth, Patricia v Auto Alliance International, Incorporated	06/21/02	020006
164	Donoho, Mary Ann v Wal-mart Stores, Incorporated	06/26/02	010260
165	Edwards, David v Peerless Gauge, Incorporated	06/27/02	010282
166	Snell, Arthur v Thyssen Steel Group	06/28/02	000091
167	Jackson, Laura v Affiliated Internists	06/28/02	010185
168	Adams, Patricia v Johnson Technology	06/28/02	010347
169	Dubois, Debra v Darden Restaurants, Incorporated	06/28/02	010439
170	Rupley, Thomas v GMC, Delphi Automotive Systems	06/28/02	010465
171	Barkowski, Jacqueline v Wal-Mart Stores, Incorporated	06/28/02	010481
172	Schmidt, James v Delphi Automotive Systems Corporation	06/28/02	010494
173	Welch, Diane v Metaldyne, Incorporated	07/01/02	010444
174	Whitten, Debbie M. v Genesis Ventures, Incorporated	07/03/02	010443
175	Eriksen, Jimmie v Cotton Regional Correctional Facility	07/08/02	010348
176	Golden, Joan v Detroit Board of Education	07/09/02	010317
177	Rodriguez, Elena v Alterra Healthcare Corporation	07/09/02	020054
178	Adams, Roger Jr. v Griffin Beverage Company	07/09/02	020088
179	Novak, Marcia v Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company	07/09/02	010464
180	Speet, Michael v Barry Haveman	07/11/02	010422
181	Mladin, Gheorghe v C. Firman & Son Construction	07/11/02	020081
182	Clark, Eryne W. Jr. v Supreme Machined Products, Incorporated	07/12/02	010458
183	Morgan, Amy M. v Johnson Controls, Incorporated	07/15/02	010493